Tocqueville
and
Beaumont recorded their observations of the houses they saw in America with great detail. The
descriptions from their diaries and journals surround Democracy in America with an intimate
account of the activities of the young Frenchmen in America. The entries also give background to
generalizations about the American character that are developed in Democracy in America.
Intrigued by the frontier, many of their
descriptions focused on experiences in Kentucky and Tennessee, "the soil in the two states
seemed still almost entirely covered by forests. Once every so often a line of rails, some burnt
trees, a field of corn, a few cattle, a cabin of tree trunks placed one on the other and roughly
squared, announced the isolated dwelling of a settler. You see hardly any villages. The
habitations of the farmers are scattered in the woods." And later adding the comment, "Nothing
is more rare to encounter a house of brick in Kentucky; we didn't see ten in Tennessee, Nashville
excepted" (Pierson, 584).
A bias for the Northern sections of the
country may be explained by such passages as this: "The interior of these dwellings
attests the indolence of the
master even more than his poverty.
You find a clean enough bed, some chairs, a good gun, often books, and almost always a
newspaper, but the walls are so full of chinks that the outside air enters from all sides with...
"You are hardly better sheltered than in a cabin of leaves. Nothing would be easier than to
protect oneself from bad weather and stop the chinks, but the master of the place is incapable of
taking such care. In the North you see reigning an air of cleanliness and intelligence in the
humblest dwellings. Here everything seems sketchy, everything a matter of chance; one would
say that the inhabitant lives from day to day in the most perfect carelessness of the future....
(Pierson, 585). This description obviously shows conflicting ideas about personal responsibility
between Tocqueville and what he identifies as the lifestyle of Southern Americans.
Tocqueville described for his
father
an image of the
typical
Tennessee cabin. This depiction is assumed to be based on the cabin where Tocqueville rested
while battling one
of his
illnesses during the trip. "It was in one of the many forested valleys of the region, he wrote, that
we discovered one evening a cabin, made of wood, whose poorly joined walls allowed one to see
a great fire flaming in the interior. We knock: two great roguish dogs, big as donkeys, come first
to the door. Their master follows close, grips us hard by the hand, and invites us to enter.You
push open a door hung on leather hinges and without a lock...Here you find a family of poor
people leading the lazy life of the rich...Not even the most miserable planter of Kentucky or
Tennessee but represents marvelously the country gentleman of old Europe. A fireplace as wide
as half the room and with an entire tree burning in it, a bed, a few chairs, a carbine six feet long,
against the walls of the apartment, a few hunter's accouterments which the wind was bowing
about as it chose, and the picture is complete. Near the fire is seated the mistress of the lodge,
with the tranquil and modest air that distinguishes American women, while four or five husky
children rolled on the floor, as lightly clad as in the month of July. Under the mantel of the
chimney two or three squatting Negroes still seemed to find that it was less warm there than in
Africa. In the midst of this collection of misery, my gentleman did not do the honours of his
house with the less ease and courtesy. It's not that he forced himself to move in any way; but the
poor blacks, soon perceiving that a stranger had entered the house, one of them by orders of the
master presented us with a glass of whisky, another, a corn cake or plate of venison; a third was
sent to get wood. The first time I saw this order given I supposed that it was a question of going
to the cellar or woodhouse; but the axe strokes that I heard ringing in the wood told me soon that
they were cutting down the tree that we needed. It's thus they do everything. While the slaves
were thus occupied, the master, seated tranquilly before a fire that would have roasted an ox to
the marrow of his bones, enveloped himself majestically in a cloud of smoke, and between each
puff related to his guests, to make their time seem less long, all the great exploits that his hunter's
memory could furnish him" (Pierson, 586).
Here is a sense of acceptiance, rather
than condemnation. Tocqueville gives an in-depth and
sensitive
description of a
backwoods cabin in Michigan, with kinder attitudes toward the New England
experience. The cabin is described in great detail and shows Tocqueville's attempts to understand
the world of the
man and woman that live in this household. This leaves us with a detailed description of the
family's home life and some ability to discern the values they held dear.
"After
this field, the rough sketch, the first step of civilization in
the wilderness, you
suddenly perceive the cabin of the proprietor. It is
generally placed in the center of a piece of land more carefully cultivated than the rest but
where man still sustains an unequal struggle
against nature. There the trees have been cut but not yet uprooted;
their trunks still garnish and clutter up the land which formerly
they shaded; about this dried debris, wheat, oak shoots, plants of all
kinds, herbs of every sort, are tangled and grow together on an indocile and still half-savage
soil. It's in the center of this vigorous and
varied vegetation that rises the planter's house, or, as it is called in
this country, the log house.
Like the surrounding field this
rustic
dwelling betrays
recent and hasty work. Its length rarely exceeds thirty feet. It is twenty wide,
fifteen high. The walls, like the roof, are formed of unsquared tree
trunks, between which moss and earth have been placed to prevent the
cold and rain penetrating into the interior of the house. As the traveler
approaches, the scene becomes more animated. Warned by the sound
of his footfall the children who were rolling in the surrounding debris
get up precipitately and flee toward the paternal refuge as if frightened
at the sight of a man, while two large half-savage dogs, with straight
ears and long muzzles, come out of the cabin growling to cover the
retreat of their young masters.
At this point the pioneer himself appears at the door of his dwelling. He throws a scrutinizing glance at the new arrival, signs to the dogs to go back inside, and hastens himself to give them the example without betraying either curiosity or uneasiness. Arrived at the doorway of the log house, the European cannot keep from throwing an astonished glance around at the spectacle it presents.
Generally this cabin has only one single window, on which is sometimes hung a muslin curtain; for in these places, where it isn't unusual to see necessaries missing, the superfluous is often found. On the hearth of trodden earth flames a resinous fire which better than daylight illuminates the interior of the building. Above this rustic hearth trophies of war or the hunt are to be seen: a long rifle, a deerskin, eagle feathers. On the right of the chimney is stretched a map of the United States which the wind, coming in through the cracks in the wall, ceaselessly lifts and agitates. Near it, on a solitary shelf of badly squared boards, are placed some ill-assorted books; there you find a Bible whose cover and edges are already worn by the piety of two generations, a book of prayers, and sometimes a song of Milton or a tragedy of Shakespeare. Along the wall are ranged some rude benches, fruit of the proprietor's industry: trunks instead of clothes cupboards, farming tools, and some samples of the harvest. In the center of the room stands a table whose uneven legs, still garnished with foliage, seem to have grown from the soil where it stands. It's there that the whole family comes together every day for meals. A teapot of English porcelain, spoons most often of wood, a few chipped cups, and some newspapers are there to be seen.
The appearance of the master of
this house is no less
remarkable
than the place that serves him as asylum. The angular muscles and
long thin arms and legs make you recognize at first glance the native
of New England. This man was not born in the solitude where he
dwells: his constitution alone proclaims that. His first years were passed
in the bosom of an intellectual and reasoning society. It's his own desire
that has thrown him into the labours of the wilderness for which he
does not seem made. But if his physical forces seem beneath his enterprise, in his face, lined
by
the cares of life, reigns an air of practical
intelligence, of cold and persevering energy, which strikes one at once.
His step is slow and very regular, his word measured and his face
austere. Habit, and pride even more, have imparted to his face that
stoic rigidity which his actions belie. The pioneer, it is true, scorns what
often most violently moves the heart of man; his goods and his life
will never be staked on the throw of the dice or the destinies of a
woman; but to become well-to-do he has braved exile, the loneliness and
the numberless miseries of the savage life, he has slept on the bare
ground, he has exposed himself to the forest fevers and the tomahawk
of the Indian. He made this effort one day, he has been renewing it
for years, he will continue it twenty years more perhaps without
becoming discouraged or complaining. Is a man, capable of such sacrifices,
a cold and insensible being? Ought not one on the contrary to recognize in him one of those
mental passions, so burning, so tenacious, so
implacable ?
Intent on the one goal of making his fortune, the emigrant has
finally created for himself an altogether individual existence. Family
sentiments have come to fuse themselves in a vast egoism, and it is
doubtful if in his wife and children he sees anything else than a detached portion of himself.
Deprived of habitual contacts with his fellows, he has learned to take a delight in solitude. When
you present
yourself on the sill of his isolated dwelling, the pioneer comes forward to meet you, he holds
out his hand according to custom, but
his face expresses neither benevolence nor joy. He only speaks to
ask questions of you. It's an intellectual not an emotional need he is
satisfying, and as soon as he has drawn from you the news he wished
to learn he falls silent again. One would suppose oneself in the presence of a man who in the
evening has retired to his dwelling, tired
of the demands and the noise of the world. There is no cordiality in
your reception. Interrogate him yourself, he will give you the information you need with
intelligence; he will even see to your necessities,
watch over your safety so long as you are under his roof; but there
reigns in all his actions so much constraint, pride; you perceive in
them such a profound indifference even for the results of your efforts,
that you feel your gratitude freezing. Yet the pioneer is hospitable in
his way, but his hospitality has nothing which touches you because in
exercising it he seems to submit himself to a painful necessity of the
wilderness; he sees in it a duty which his position imposes on him, not
a pleasure. This unknown man is the representative of a race to which
belongs the future of the new world: a restless, reasoning, adventurous
race which does coldly what only the ardour of passion can explain; race
cold and passionate, which traffics in everything, not excepting morality
and religion; nation of conquerors who submit themselves to the savage life without ever
allowing themselves to be seduced by it, who in
civilization and enlightenment love only what is useful to well-being,
and who shut themselves in the American solitudes with an axe and
some newspapers.
A people which, like all great peoples, has but one thought, and
which is advancing toward the acquisition of riches, sole goal of its
efforts, with a perseverance and a scorn for life that one might call
heroic, if that name fitted other than virtuous things.
It's this nomad people which the rivers and lakes do not stop, before which the forests fall and the prairies are covered with shade, and which, after having reached the Pacific ocean, will reverse its steps to trouble and destroy the societies which it will have formed behind it.
In speaking of the pioneer one cannot forget the companion of his miseries and dangers. Look across the hearth at the young woman, who, while seeing to the preparation of the meal, rocks her youngest son on her knees. Like the emigrant, this woman is in her prime; like him, she can recall the ease of her first years. Her clothes even yet proclaim a taste for adornment ill extinguished. But time has weighed heavily on her: in her prematurely pale face and her shrunken limbs it is easy to see that existence has been a heavy burden for her. In fact, this frail creature has already found herself exposed to unbelievable miseries. Scarce entered upon life, she had to tear herself away from the mother's tenderness and from those sweet fraternal ties that a young girl never abandons without shedding tears, even when going to share the rich dwelling of a new husband. The wife of the pioneer has torn herself in one instant and without hope of returning from that innocent cradle of her youth. It's against the solitude of the forests that she has exchanged the charms of society and the joys of the home. It's on the bare ground of the wilderness that her nuptial couch was placed. To devote herself to austere duties, submit herself to privations which were unknown to her, embrace an existence for which she was not made, such was the occupation of the finest years of her life, such have been for her the delights of marriage. Want, suffering, and loneliness have affected her constitution but not bowed her courage. 'Mid the profound sadness painted on her delicate features, you easily remark a religious resignation and profound peace and I know not what natural and tranquil firmness confronting all the miseries of life without fearing or scorning them.
Around this woman crowd half naked children, shining with health, careless of the morrow, veritable sons of the wilderness. From time to time their mother throws on them a look of melancholy and joy. To see their strength and her weakness one would say that she has exhausted herself giving them life and that she does not regret what they have cost her.
The house inhabited by these emigrants has no interior partitions or attic. In the single apartment which it contains the entire family comes in the evening to seek refuge: this dwelling forms of itself a small world. It's the ark of civilization lost in the midst of an ocean of leaves. It's a sort of oasis in the desert. A hundred feet beyond, the eternal forest stretches about it its shade and the solitude begins again" (Pierson, 242-45).
The journal entries focus on descriptions of the rural cabins and their inhabitants rather than the city homes. Naturally, the rural American lifestyle was uncommon in the young men's realm of experience and of greater interest than those of cities. As a result, there are fewer detailed descriptions of northern cities. However, Beaumont wrote of the homes in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, "All the houses are brick, and without portes cocheres following the English custom, and the streets straight as a string. The regularity is tiresome but very convenient" (Pierson, 458). Obviously not as intriguing for the tourist.
There is also a description of
Tocqueville's first impressions of New York as the ship was coming into port. This 1830 home
might be similar to
what deTocqueville described,
"Picture to yourself an attractively varied shoreline, the slopes
covered by
lawns and trees in bloom right down to the water, and more than all that, an unbelievable
multitude of country houses, big as boxes of candy, but showing careful workmanship...I have
been so struck by how convenient these little houses must be, and by the attractive air they gave
the countryside (Pierson, 56). Apparently the traveling companions had different connotations for
the term "convenient".