|
Sound
and Fury in Germany
Alice Hamilton, M.D.
Professor of Industrial Medicine, Harvard Medical School
November 1933
WE tried also to discover what was happening
to the social services which had reached such a high degree of
efficiency under the Republican government, but it was hard to
learn any thing definite, partly because the social workers to
whom wc had introductions were already either discharged or on
compulsory leave. They did not venture to go back to their offices
and were dependent on rumor for news of what was happening to
their former activities. Not only Jews but Social Democrats, liberals,
or people with no political affiliations but closely connected
with the former government, almost all of them were at least temporarily
suspended from work. Whether any have been readmitted, I cannot
say, except that by the middle of June practically every social
worker of Jewish blood had been discharged, even the public-health
nurses. It meant a very serious crippling of the services, for
the majority of the workers came in under one of the above heads.
There were rumors that came to us now and
then, an individual instance, such as a building which had been
used as a health and recreation center for young mothers with
babies, being turned into Nazi barracks; or an old castle which
had been made habitable and given to the Pathfinders for a night
shelter being turned into a concentration camp for political heretics.
But what the real policy of the new regime was, nobody knew. A
few significant statements appeared in the papers, without comment.
Thus we read that Kerrl, the new head of the penal system, declared
that sentimental and softhearted measures with prisoners were
to be abandoned. The new prison administration was to be founded
on strict discipline and all societies connected with prisons,
reformatories, courts, and so on were dissolved.
Goering, the soldier aviator, is hardly an
expert on relief, yet he has the power to dictate what form it
shall take and he is strong for private charity as against public
relief. At an official press conference on June 9 he announced
the fundamental lines on which the new system of relief is to
be organized. "The experience of the past shows that it was a
grave error to entrust welfare to public bodies. This meant that
public relief was introduced in places where private charity was
already sufficient, thus hampering the latter."
|
|
The central figure is Hermann Goering,
Prussian premier, president of the Reichstag,
aviator, who has the power to dictate what form
relief shall take. He is opposed to public relief
|
An enthusiastic young Hitlerite took us to
see the sort of relief which Goering approves, a soup-kitchen
maintained by employed Nazis for the unemployed of the party.
Each family in which there is a member with a job contributes
a pound of food a week to the kitchen. I must say I have never
seen a friendlier or cheerier place. It was an old dwelling-house,
once grand but now hopelessly shabby; and it was dubiously clean,
it was crowded and noisy, but it had an atmosphere of comradeship
and warmth and even pride, which no other such place I ever visited
had. The kitchen was filled with red-faced, perspiring women stirring
great soup-kettles and washing thick bowls, and in two big dining-rooms
were crowds of young men eating thick soup and rye bread. Our
guide was a stout, hearty, beaming Nazi lady who bustled into
each room with a Fascist salute and a loud "Heil" and all
the cooks and the diners responded with a "Heil." Nobody
paid for the food he ate and nobody asked pay for the work she
did.
I might have waxed quite sentimental over
it had I not once been a social worker myself and know how little
such individual efforts however sweet can do to stem the great
tide of hunger and misery in a country like Germany under the
present depression. What is to be the Iot of the poor who have
no Nazi record, nobody knows.
The Nazi leaders have for years denounced
the government of the Republic and now their propaganda is one
of unmitigated vilification of all that was done by the state
between 1919 and 1933. The Socialists they hold responsible for
the Armistice, which they call "a stab in the back," for the army
was never defeated, the generals were only too eager to carry
on, and had it not been for the Jews and pacifists in Berlin,
Germany would have emerged victorious from the War. Having ruined
their country in a military sense, the Jews and Marxists proceeded
to ruin her economically, through the inflation and then through
widespread corruption and robbery. This is reiterated so often
that people whose memories should serve them better, begin to
believe it.
AS to the charge that Socialists were responsible
for the collapse at the Front in the fall of 1918, Philip Scheidemann
has answered that in The New York Times. I asked several social
workers whether there was any justification for Goebbels' attacks
on the Republican government. One of them, whose name is known
to most Survey Graphic readers, answered as follows:
It was not a corrupt government and
much that it did was of lasting value, but it was partizan and
sometimes the program was illiudged. No one party was responsible,
city and state governments had to have representatives of all
parties and these always fought for places for their followers.
Then after the inflation was over and the mark stabilized, the
Germans thought prosperity had come to stay and the administrations
put up extravagant buildings and laid out parks. But the 6-million-dollar
Krankenkassen building in Frankfurt was not more foolish than
the enormous building put up by I. G. Farben (the dye and chemical
trust) at the same time. Foreign loans were only too easy to get,
in fact your American bankers almost forced them on us. However,
it is true that there was not, after the War, the same incorruptible
official class as before and for the first time the political
parties dictated appointments, such as burgomasters, who before
were always non-partizan specialists. It is true that the Cabinet
was not Socialistic after the first year, but the Department of
the Interior always was. Salaries also were higher than before
the War. Everywhere except in Bavaria, the officials were practically
all Socialistic. The Socialists were not always corrupt, but they
did take all offices, even the smallest, for themselves, and they
had autos and lived in grand houses. All the old standards, of
small salaries and modest living, were gone and men who never
before had had large sums of money to spend lost their heads.
Now many cities are bankrupt. Hitler and his colleagues are wise
enough to live with the utmost simplicity.
A lady who had done volunteer social service
before the war also protested against the injustice done to the
Republican government by Hitler. She spoke of the twelve-hour
day, which obtained in many industries before the War, abolished
by the Socialists and she insisted that, with all his unemployment
and his miserable dole, the workman is better off in Berlin now
than he was then, his housing is better, he has his insurances,
he has gained enormously.
|