[Excerpted from The Limits of Sisterhood, pp. 200-1. Originally published in Putnam's Magazine, November and December 1868.]from A Mother's Letters to a Daughter on Woman Suffrage.
by Isabella Beecher Hooker
MY DEAR DAUGHTER:
You ask me what I think of the modesty and sense of a woman who can insist, in these days, that she is not sufficiently cared for in public and in private, and who wishes to add the duties of a politician to those of a mother and housekeeper....
. . . [L]et me begin by asking you the meaning of the word politician. Having consulted your dictionary, you reply, "One who is versed in the science of government and the art of governing." Very well. Now who is thus versed in the science and art of governing, so far as the family is concerned, more than the mother of it? In this country, certainly, the manners, the habits, the laws of a household, are determined in great part by the mother; so much so, that when we see lying and disobedient children, or coarse, untidy and ill-mannered ones, we instinctively make our comments on the mother of that brood, and declare her more or less incompetent to her place.
Now let me suppose her to be one of the competent ones who, like your Aunt E., has helped six stout boys and four of their quick-witted sisters all the way from babyhood up to manhood and womanhood, with a wisdom and gentleness and patience that have been the wonder of all beholders -- and let us think of her as sitting down now in her half-forsaken nest, calm, thoughtful, and matured, but fresh in her feeling as ever she was . . . and what wonder if she finds it hard to realize that she is unfitted either by nature or education for the work of law making, on a broader and larger scale than she has ever yet tried.
Her youngest boy, the privileged, saucy one of the crowd, has just attained his majority, we will say, and declaims in her hearing on the incompetence of women to vote -- the superiority of the masculine element in politics, and the danger to society if women are not carefully guarded from contact with its rougher elements -- and I seem to see her quiet smile and slightly curling lip, while in memory she runs back to the years when said stripling gathered all he knew of laws, country, home, heaven, and earth, at her knee -- "and as for soiling contacts, oh! my son, who taught you to avoid these, and first put it into your curly little head, that evil communications corrupt good manners, and that 'e man cannottouch pitch, except he be defiled.'"
I have taken the bull by the horns, you perceive in thus taking our mother from her quiet country home and setting her by imagination among the legislators of the land; -- but it is just as well, because the practical end of suffrage is, not eligibility to office merely, but a largeruse of this privilege than most women have ever yet dreamed of, much less desired....
... I am always your affectionate
Mother.